Tuesday, July 23, 2013

The Cripple of Inishmaan


On the Irish island of Inishmaan in 1934, young Billy Claven's life is less than he'd hoped. Billy is an outcast from his small town due to the rumors surrounding his parents' purported suicide and the deformities in his arms and legs. However, Billy is given an opportunity to escape the confines of his home when a Hollywood documentary crew arrives at the neighboring island of Inishmore, with Billy believing he can escape the dull monotony of Inishmaan if he just gets the chance to impress them.

The Cripple of Inishmaan is a play by Martin McDonagh, a writer I've been a fan of after seeing his debut film In Bruges (which was nominated for the Oscar for Best Original Screenplay). After reading and seeing some of his other work, it occurs to me to try and find common themes and topics in them, and Cripple definitely falls into those modes. On display is a dark sense of humor, minor swipes at Catholicism and the Catholic Church, and an ambiguous ending, all of which crop up in McDonagh's other work. However, of the (admittedly limited) list of McDonagh's plays I've read, Cripple has the most in common with an even darker and bleaker comedy, The Lonesome West. Both poke fun at rural Irish life and laugh at the inadequacies and peculiarities of those that live it. However, Lonesome West takes it a step farther in acknowledging how dark its characters truly are and how, even when you're laughing at them, you're meant to remember how callous and cruel they are. Conversely, Cripple takes the attitude of "they don't know any better", to the point where a character is confused at the prospect of not laughing at Billy's deformities.

The core theme of Cripple seems to be that everyone in Inishmaan has a deformity - the only difference is that Billy's are physical rather than mental, and he can't hide them or escape from them. Billy's crush, Helen McCormick, is violent and abrasive while being completely unaware that that's unusual. Her brother, Bartley, is comically stupid. Billy's caretakers are Eileen, who compulsively eats when stressed, and Kate, who takes up conversations with stones when stressed. All the characters (save, perhaps, Dr. McSharry, who has a minor role in the story) have an inadequacy, a vice, or simply a defect, which puts them on equal footing with Billy, even if they don't know it.

The Cripple of Inishmaan is ultimately a showcase for some of McDonagh's best qualities as a writer: his pitch-black sense of humor and his ability to find the core humanity in the characters his so mercilessly mocks. It's a fantastic show and highly recommended to anyone who can stomach a crippled man being mocked and abused for two hours.

No comments:

Post a Comment